After extensive research (by which I mean far too many hours spent lurking in baking forums and down a YouTube rabbit hole), I’ve finally compiled a list of the best muffin tins that are worth their weight in gold—or at least, in flour. And speaking of flour, these days I’ve been experimenting with oat, chickpea, and almond flours because, you know, #health. I try to swap out at least half the regular flour in any recipe for something a bit more nutritious. The results? Some triumphs, some…not so much. I wouldn’t recommend it unless, like me, you enjoy a little kitchen improv—though in baking, winging it is definitely not ideal. Precision, people!
A muffin pan is perfect for muffins, but also for egg cups, cupcakes, and my personal favorite: homemade healthy-ish peanut butter cups.
That said, the right muffin pan is a non-negotiable. Whether you’re whipping up brunch, snack time treats, or some experimental flour concoction, having the right pan makes all the difference. But who knew there were so many types? Let’s take a minute to appreciate the wide, wonderful world of muffin pans. Here’s your go-to guide to the best muffin tins (complete with product suggestions, naturally).
The Best Muffin Tins & Muffin Pans
1. Nordic Ware Aluminum Non-Stick Muffin Tin
Think of this as the little black dress of muffin tins. It’s reliable and will never let you down. Its non-stick surface ensures your muffins slide right out, and it’s made of sturdy aluminum, which means it’ll last forever. It’s the one you’ll reach for again and again, whether it’s blueberry muffins or a batch of savory breakfast cups.
Plus, it’s Wirecutter approved, which goes a long way in our book. Simply put, a classic choice that never disappoints.
2. Silpat Original Perfect Muffin Mold
It’s flexible, heat-resistant, and honestly, kind of fun to use. Plus, it’s dishwasher safe, which speaks to my lazy girl soul. The Silpat mold takes non-stick to a whole new level. Plus, it’s flexible, so you can pop out your muffins with ease. No need for liners or greasing the pan—just bake, cool, and voilà! It’s also super easy to clean, which is always a bonus when you’ve got more important things to do.
3. Nordic Ware Petite Muffin Tin
Feeling mini? The Nordic Ware Petite Muffin Pan lets you bake 24 adorable bite-sized muffins in one go. Perfect for gatherings, kids’ snacks, or when you just want a little treat without fully committing to a full-sized muffin (because sometimes we just want a taste, not a meal). Also perfect for those of us who believe that the correct serving size for muffins is “as many as I can fit in my mouth at once.”
4. Caraway Ceramic Muffin Pan
If aesthetics matter to you as much as your muffins (and let’s be real, they do), the Caraway Ceramic Muffin Pan is your dream pan. This beauty doesn’t just bake muffins; it sits on your counter looking chic while doing it. With a naturally slick ceramic surface, it’s both non-toxic and non-stick, so no need to worry about harmful chemicals. Plus, it comes in those signature Caraway colors that’ll make you want to display it proudly.
5. Lodge Cast Iron Muffin Pan Set
For those who want to bring a little nostalgia into their baking, the Lodge Cast Iron Muffin Pan is a solid (literally) choice. Cast iron distributes heat evenly, so your muffins will bake beautifully, and this pan will last for generations. Yes, it’s heavier than your usual bakeware, but that’s part of the charm. Just imagine pulling perfectly golden muffins out of the oven while feeling like you’ve mastered the art of rustic living.
6. Silver Foil Cupcake Liners
You can bake muffins right in foil liners placed on a baking sheet—no muffin pan needed! Just make sure to space them out a bit to allow for even air circulation. To prevent any sticking, try greasing the bottoms of the foil cups with a little oil or spray oil (we like coconut oil or avocado oil spray).
7. Nordic Ware Muffin Pan With Handles
Sometimes it’s the little things, like handles on your muffin pan, that make a huge difference. The Nordic Ware Muffin Pan with Handles gives you a solid grip as you move your muffins in and out of the oven, no awkward juggling necessary. It’s non-stick, too, so you get practicality and ease with every batch.
8. Nordic Ware Muffin Pan with Lid
A muffin pan that comes with a lid? Yes, please. Bake your muffins, pop the lid on, and you’re ready to transport them to picnics, parties, or simply stash them away for the week.
